Blog

You walk past your furnace on a cold January morning and spot a puddle forming underneath. Your heart sinks. Is this dangerous? Will your heating fail when you need it most?

Here’s some info that might help: water pooling around your furnace during winter is actually one of the more common service calls we receive at Tuck & Howell, especially when temperatures drop below freezing. While it can feel uncertain at times, understanding what’s happening and knowing the right steps to take can help you protect your home and stay comfortable through the coldest months.

At Tuck & Howell Plumbing, Heating & Air, we’ve helped many homeowners across Anderson County, Greenville County, Henderson County, and surrounding areas resolve furnace leaks quickly and safely. Let’s walk through what causes these leaks, what you should do immediately, and how to keep it from happening again.

Why Is My Furnace Leaking Water in Winter?

The short answer: most furnace leaks happen with high-efficiency condensing furnaces (those with an efficiency rating of 90% or higher). These modern systems are designed to extract more heat from exhaust gases, which creates moisture as a natural byproduct.

Here’s what typically happens: Your high-efficiency furnace produces condensation, sometimes several gallons per day during peak winter use. This water needs to drain away through a dedicated line. When temperatures plummet or debris builds up, that drainage system can fail.

You’ll usually recognize a high-efficiency furnace by its white PVC exhaust pipes. If your furnace has a metal flue pipe instead, it’s likely a conventional model that shouldn’t produce condensation under normal conditions. Water around a conventional furnace often points to an external issue like a plumbing leak nearby.

What Actually Causes the Water?

Clogged condensate drain lines top the list. As your furnace runs throughout winter, dirt, algae, and debris can accumulate in the drainage tubing. Eventually, the line gets blocked, and water backs up instead of flowing out. In homes across Buncombe County and Pickens County, we coordinate with homeowners who notice this issue most often after their furnace has been running nonstop during cold snaps.

Frozen drain lines become a real problem when temperatures stay below freezing for extended periods. If your condensate line runs through an unheated space like a crawlspace or along an exterior wall without proper insulation, the water inside can freeze solid. Once frozen, there’s nowhere for new condensation to go except backward into your furnace area.

Faulty condensate pumps can also be the culprit. Many furnaces use a small pump to move water up and out of the system (especially in basements where gravity drainage isn’t possible). These pumps wear out over time, and winter’s continuous operation can push an aging pump past its limit.

Cracked heat exchangers or damaged inducer assemblies represent more serious problems. While less common, cracks in these components can allow water to leak where it shouldn’t. This type of damage can also create carbon monoxide risks, which is why professional HVAC maintenance becomes so important.

Humidifier issues round out the common causes. If you have a whole-house humidifier attached to your furnace, it has its own water supply and drain. Connections can loosen, drain pans can overflow, or the unit itself might develop leaks. During dry winter months when your humidifier works harder, these problems become more noticeable.

Is a Leaking Furnace Dangerous?

The water itself won’t hurt you, but the underlying cause might signal bigger concerns. Here’s what you should know:

Water damage and mold growth can develop quickly if leaks continue. Even small amounts of moisture on floors, drywall, or insulation create conditions for mold to thrive within 24 to 48 hours.

If the leak comes from a cracked heat exchanger, you’re facing a potential carbon monoxide hazard. Heat exchangers separate combustion gases from the air circulating through your home. A crack compromises that separation. While water leaking is just one possible symptom, any suspicion of heat exchanger damage needs immediate professional attention.

System inefficiency happens when water backs up into your furnace. The condensation process is part of how high-efficiency models achieve their ratings. When drainage fails, the system can’t operate as designed, leading to higher energy bills and inadequate heating.

That’s why we always tell homeowners to treat furnace leaks seriously, even if everything seems to be working fine otherwise.

What Should I Do If My Furnace Is Leaking Water?

Step 1: Turn off your furnace immediately. Locate your thermostat and switch it to “off” mode. If you’re comfortable doing so, you can also flip the emergency shutoff switch near your furnace or turn off the circuit breaker. This stops new condensation from forming and prevents potential water damage from getting worse.

Step 2: Clean up the water. Use towels, a wet/dry vacuum, or a mop to remove standing water. Pay attention to areas under and around the furnace. Place towels or a shallow pan under the leak source if you can safely identify it. This temporary measure helps minimize damage while you wait for professional help.

Step 3: Contact a licensed HVAC technician right away. At Tuck & Howell Plumbing, Heating & Air, we work to ensure quick response times because we understand how critical heating is during winter months. A qualified professional can diagnose the exact cause, whether it’s a simple clog or something more complex, and provide the right solution.

Generally, furnace leaks require expertise to diagnose correctly. While you might be tempted to investigate on your own, components like heat exchangers and condensate systems need professional evaluation to ensure both safety and proper repair.

Step 4: Don’t run your furnace until it’s been inspected. We know it’s cold, but continuing to operate a leaking furnace can cause more extensive damage. Use space heaters safely in critical areas if needed, and avoid leaving them unattended.

What Will a Technician Check?

When we respond to a furnace leak call, here’s our typical approach:

• Inspect the condensate drain line for clogs, checking from the furnace all the way to the exit point
• Test the condensate pump (if your system has one) to verify it’s moving water properly
• Examine the heat exchanger and inducer assembly for cracks or damage
• Check humidifier connections and operation if one is installed
• Look for frozen sections in exposed drain lines
• Assess the overall system condition to catch potential issues before they become problems

This thorough inspection helps identify not just the immediate leak source, but any related concerns that might affect your system’s safety and efficiency.

How Can I Prevent Furnace Leaks in Winter?

Prevention centers on one key practice: annual professional maintenance. We recommend scheduling your furnace tune-up in early fall, before the heating season starts. During these visits, we help ensure your system is ready for months of reliable operation.

What Maintenance Includes

Condensate drain cleaning removes buildup before it causes blockages. Technicians flush the line and verify proper flow, which is especially important for high-efficiency models that produce significant moisture.

Filter replacement improves airflow and system efficiency. Dirty filters force your furnace to work harder, potentially affecting condensation patterns and drainage.

Heat exchanger inspection catches cracks or corrosion early, before they become safety hazards or cause leaks.

Condensate pump testing ensures the pump will handle winter’s demands without failure.

System component check covers everything from burners to blower motors, identifying wear that could lead to problems mid-season.

Between professional visits, homeowners can take simple steps too:

Change your air filter regularly (typically every 1-3 months during heavy use). A clean filter helps your entire system function better.

Keep the area around your furnace clear so air can circulate properly and you can spot potential issues early.

Monitor your thermostat for unusual behavior like frequent cycling or difficulty reaching set temperatures, which might indicate developing problems.

Listen for odd sounds such as gurgling near the condensate line or unusual furnace noises that weren’t there before.

Check visible portions of the condensate line occasionally, especially during cold snaps, to ensure water is flowing and nothing looks frozen or blocked.

For homeowners in areas like Spartanburg County, and Polk County where winter temperatures can be particularly harsh, consider asking your technician about drain line insulation or heat tape for exposed sections. These additions provide extra protection against freezing.

Can I Fix a Furnace Leak Myself?

While some maintenance tasks are homeowner-friendly, furnace leak repairs usually require professional expertise. Here’s why:

Diagnosis can be complex. What looks like a simple clog might actually be a frozen line, a failing pump, or a cracked component. Misidentifying the problem can lead to incomplete repairs and recurring leaks.

Safety concerns matter. Working around gas furnaces, electrical components, and potential carbon monoxide risks isn’t worth the danger. Licensed technicians have the training and equipment to work safely.

Proper tools and parts are essential. Clearing certain blockages, replacing pumps, or repairing heat exchangers requires specialized equipment and manufacturer-specific parts.

Warranty protection depends on professional service. Many furnace warranties require that repairs be performed by licensed professionals. DIY attempts might void your coverage.

That said, you can handle basic tasks like changing air filters and keeping the furnace area clean. For everything else, consult your technician.

What About Different Furnace Types?

Understanding your furnace type helps set expectations:

High-efficiency condensing furnaces (90%+ AFUE) with PVC pipes naturally produce condensation. Leaks typically relate to drainage issues and are generally repairable without major replacement.

Conventional furnaces (80% AFUE) with metal flue pipes shouldn’t produce condensation under normal operation. Water around these units often indicates external plumbing issues, humidifier problems, or in rare cases, exhaust system failures.

Electric furnaces don’t produce combustion gases or condensation. Water around an electric furnace almost always comes from an external source like a nearby plumbing leak or attached humidifier.

If you’re unsure which type you have, your HVAC technician can identify it during the service call.

When Is It Time for Furnace Replacement?

Sometimes a leak reveals that your furnace has reached the end of its useful life. Consider replacement if:

• Your heat exchanger is cracked. This is often not economical to repair, especially on older units.
• The furnace is 15-20 years old and experiencing multiple issues beyond just the leak.
• Repair costs approach 50% or more of a new furnace’s value.
• Your energy bills have been climbing despite regular maintenance, indicating declining efficiency.

Modern high-efficiency furnaces offer significant improvements in both comfort and energy savings. If replacement makes sense for your situation, we help ensure you select the right size and efficiency level for your home and coordinate proper installation.

Get Expert Help from Tuck & Howell

Since 1969, families across Greer, SC, and the surrounding areas have trusted Tuck & Howell Plumbing, Heating & Air for reliable HVAC service. When your furnace starts leaking in the middle of winter, you need responsive, professional help you can count on.

Our technicians treat your home with the same care we’d give our own. We diagnose the real problem, explain your options clearly, and provide solutions that restore your comfort and peace of mind.

Whether you’re dealing with an active leak right now or you want to schedule preventative maintenance before problems develop, we’re here to help. Reach out to see “Howell” . We’re different when it comes to keeping your home warm and dry all winter long.

FAQs About Furnace Leaking Water in Winter

Why is my high-efficiency furnace leaking water when it’s cold outside?

Cold temperatures can freeze condensate in drain lines, especially if they run through unheated spaces. Your furnace produces more condensation during extended cold periods because it runs more frequently. When drainage is blocked by ice or debris, water backs up and leaks around the unit. Contact a professional to inspect and clear the line safely.

Is it normal for a furnace to produce water?

Yes, high-efficiency condensing furnaces (90% AFUE or higher) naturally produce water as they extract heat from exhaust gases. This condensation should drain away through dedicated lines. Water pooling around your furnace indicates a drainage problem, not normal operation. Conventional furnaces shouldn’t produce condensation under typical conditions.

Can a clogged air filter cause my furnace to leak water?

Indirectly, yes. A severely clogged filter restricts airflow, which can affect temperature patterns in your furnace and potentially impact condensation drainage. While it’s not the most common cause of leaks, keeping your filter clean supports proper system operation overall. If you’re experiencing leaks, address the immediate drainage issue first, then maintain regular filter changes going forward.

How much does it cost to fix a furnace water leak?

Repair costs vary based on the specific issue, parts needed, and your location. Simple drain line cleaning typically costs less than replacing a condensate pump or repairing major components. For an accurate estimate tailored to your system, contact a local licensed HVAC professional like Tuck & Howell Plumbing, Heating & Air. We provide clear pricing before beginning any repair work.

Should I turn off my furnace if it’s leaking water?

Yes. Turn off your furnace immediately when you notice a leak. This stops new condensation from forming, prevents potential water damage, and keeps you safe while waiting for professional diagnosis. Use alternative heating sources carefully until a technician can inspect your system and make necessary repairs.

Can frozen condensate lines damage my furnace?

Frozen lines prevent proper drainage, causing water to back up into your system. While the ice itself doesn’t typically damage the furnace, the backed-up water can affect components and operation. More importantly, continued attempts to run a furnace with blocked drainage can lead to more serious problems. Have frozen lines addressed by a professional who can safely thaw them and prevent future freezing.

How often should I schedule furnace maintenance to prevent leaks?

Annual maintenance is strongly recommended, ideally in early fall before the heating season begins. During these tune-ups, technicians clean condensate lines, check pumps, inspect heat exchangers, and address issues before they cause mid-winter breakdowns. This preventative approach is especially important for high-efficiency models that rely on proper drainage. Regular maintenance improves efficiency and catches potential problems early.